The Maps We Carry: When Other People Help Draw Our Maps

How Conversations, Relationships, and Social Influence Shape What We Believe About Others

Have you ever changed your opinion about someone after hearing another person's experience with them?

Maybe you liked a coworker until someone told you they were difficult to work with.

Perhaps you felt uncertain about a friendship until someone you trusted pointed out a pattern you had not recognized.

Or maybe you had a difficult interaction with a family member, talked about it with several people, and gradually became more certain about what the interaction meant.

Sometimes these conversations help us understand situations more accurately.

Other times, they introduce interpretations we might never have considered on our own.

And occasionally, we begin remembering an interaction through the explanation someone else provided.

This raises an interesting question.

How much of what we believe about other people comes from our own experiences, and how much comes from the people who help us interpret those experiences?

We often think of our understanding of relationships as something we develop individually.

We observe behavior, experience emotions, remember interactions, and form conclusions.

But interpersonal meaning-making is also a social process.

Other people help us interpret what happens.

They offer explanations, identify patterns, challenge assumptions, and sometimes reinforce beliefs we already hold.

In the Cartographic Model of Interpersonal Meaning-Making, this is an important part of how our interpersonal maps are created and revised.

We do not draw every part of our maps alone.

Sometimes other people help us understand the territory.

And sometimes they influence how we see it before we have had an opportunity to explore it ourselves.

Our Interpersonal Maps Are Socially Constructed

Imagine that you are starting a new job.

Before meeting your supervisor, several coworkers tell you that the supervisor is intimidating and difficult to please.

One person describes them as overly critical.

Another says they rarely acknowledge good work.

A third warns you not to ask too many questions.

You have not yet had a meaningful interaction with this person.

But you already have expectations.

During your first meeting, your supervisor asks you to explain how you approached a particular task.

You immediately feel nervous.

You wonder whether they are questioning your competence.

You become cautious in your responses.

Perhaps you offer lengthy explanations because you are afraid of making a mistake.

The supervisor notices your hesitation and asks additional questions.

Now the interaction feels increasingly uncomfortable.

You leave thinking that your coworkers were probably right.

But consider what happened.

Your understanding of the supervisor began forming before you had direct experience with them.

Information acquired from other people influenced your expectations.

Those expectations affected your emotional response and behavior.

The interaction then became additional information that appeared to support the map you had already begun constructing.

Of course, your coworkers may have been entirely accurate.

Perhaps the supervisor really is excessively critical.

But the example illustrates something important.

Our interpersonal maps can be influenced by information we receive before we directly encounter the territory.

The Difference Between Experience and Socially Acquired Information

In the Cartographic Model, one of the central questions involves the origin of the information contributing to an interpersonal representation.

I use the term epistemic provenance to describe where a particular piece of information came from.

Consider the following statements:

"I heard my supervisor criticize a coworker's presentation."

"My coworker told me the supervisor frequently humiliates employees."

"I felt anxious when the supervisor asked me a question."

"I believe the supervisor was trying to embarrass me."

These statements contribute different kinds of information.

The first describes a direct observation.

The second describes information acquired from another person.

The third describes an emotional experience.

The fourth describes an inference about intention.

All four may be relevant to understanding the situation.

But they are not equivalent.

Someone else's account may provide valuable information about behavior we have not witnessed.

Our emotional experience may alert us to something important.

And our inferences may help us develop hypotheses about what is happening.

The challenge arises when we stop distinguishing among these sources.

We may begin treating something we heard as though we observed it ourselves.

We may begin treating an interpretation as though it were an established fact.

Or we may forget that a particular explanation originated with someone else.

Understanding where information came from helps us evaluate how much confidence to place in different parts of our map.

When Other People Help Us See What We Missed

Social influence is not inherently problematic.

In fact, other people can be essential to developing a more accurate understanding of our relationships.

Imagine someone who has spent years in a relationship where their partner regularly monitors their whereabouts, discourages contact with friends, and becomes angry when they make independent decisions.

The person may have come to understand these behaviors as expressions of concern or affection.

Perhaps they have repeatedly been told that the monitoring occurs because their partner worries about their safety.

Then a trusted friend notices the pattern.

The friend asks questions about how much freedom the person has to make decisions.

They express concern about the isolation.

They help the person recognize that the behavior may reflect coercive control rather than ordinary relationship concern.

This conversation may fundamentally change how the person understands the relationship.

And that change may be important.

Sometimes other people provide language for experiences we have struggled to describe.

They may recognize patterns we have normalized.

They may identify inconsistencies that deserve attention.

They may help us understand how power, coercion, manipulation, or other relational dynamics are operating.

In these circumstances, socially acquired information can improve the accuracy of our maps.

The goal is not to distrust outside perspectives.

It is to understand how those perspectives contribute to our conclusions.

When Someone Else's Interpretation Becomes Our Own

Now consider a different situation.

You have an uncomfortable conversation with a friend.

During the interaction, your friend seems distracted and responds briefly.

You leave feeling disappointed.

Later, you describe the interaction to someone you trust.

They respond, "That sounds like your friend was deliberately trying to make you feel unimportant."

You had not considered that possibility.

Initially, you are uncertain.

But as you think about the interaction, the explanation begins to feel increasingly plausible.

You remember the friend's tone.

You recall that they looked at their phone during the conversation.

You begin connecting these observations to the interpretation you were given.

The next time you discuss the interaction, you may say, "My friend was trying to make me feel unimportant."

Notice the shift.

You began with an observation.

Your friend seemed distracted.

You experienced an emotion.

You felt disappointed.

Someone else introduced an interpretation.

Your friend was intentionally making you feel unimportant.

Over time, that interpretation became part of how you understood the event.

This does not mean the interpretation was necessarily inaccurate.

But it illustrates how socially acquired explanations can become integrated into our interpersonal maps.

Sometimes we are no longer simply remembering what happened.

We are remembering what happened through the meaning that developed afterward.

How Conversations Can Influence Memory

Research on memory suggests that remembering is not simply the retrieval of an unchanged recording.

Memory involves reconstructive processes.

Our recollections can be influenced by subsequent experiences, conversations, expectations, and information learned after an event.

Research on source monitoring examines how people identify the origins of remembered information.

For example, we may remember a detail but become uncertain whether we directly observed it, heard about it from someone else, or inferred it later.

Studies of social transmission of memory also demonstrate that information shared between people can influence subsequent recollections.

This does not mean that conversations automatically produce false memories.

Talking about experiences can help people remember important details, organize complicated information, and correct misunderstandings.

But social exchanges can also introduce information that becomes difficult to distinguish from our original experience.

Imagine that several family members are discussing an event from childhood.

One person remembers a particular argument.

Another adds details about what someone supposedly intended.

A third person provides an explanation based on something they learned years later.

Over time, the family's shared understanding may incorporate all these elements.

Some may be accurate observations.

Some may be reasonable inferences.

Others may reflect incomplete or mistaken information.

Eventually, the story becomes familiar.

And familiarity can make it difficult to remember which details came from which sources.

This is one reason epistemic provenance matters.

It helps us distinguish what we remember experiencing from what we subsequently learned or concluded.

Why Repetition Can Make an Interpretation Feel More Convincing

Imagine that you tell the same story about a difficult relationship to several people.

Each person agrees with your interpretation.

You discuss the experience repeatedly.

You hear similar explanations from friends, family members, and online communities.

Over time, the interpretation becomes increasingly familiar.

You may feel more confident because so many people appear to share your understanding.

But agreement and independent evidence are not always the same thing.

Suppose five people agree that someone behaved manipulatively.

If all five people are relying on the same description of the interaction, their agreement does not necessarily represent five independent sources of evidence.

They may simply be responding to the same information.

That does not make their perspectives worthless.

They may recognize patterns, identify concerning behavior, or provide useful conceptual frameworks.

But the distinction matters.

A conclusion supported by multiple independent observations is different from a conclusion repeated by multiple people who rely on the same account.

This is especially relevant when information spreads through social networks.

As an interpretation is repeated, its original source may become less visible.

People may begin discussing a conclusion without knowing whether it originated from direct observation, secondhand information, or inference.

Eventually, the interpretation may appear more established than the underlying evidence warrants.

When Groups Develop Shared Maps

Interpersonal meaning-making does not occur only between individuals.

Groups also develop shared understandings of people and events.

Families may develop narratives about particular members.

Workplaces may establish reputations about employees or supervisors.

Friend groups may collectively interpret conflicts.

Professional communities may develop shared explanations for someone's behavior.

These narratives can influence how group members respond to new information.

Consider a family in which one person has long been described as irresponsible.

Over time, other family members may interpret that person's behavior through the established narrative.

If they forget an appointment, the mistake confirms their irresponsibility.

If they make an independent decision, others may question whether they can be trusted.

If they demonstrate consistent responsibility, the change may receive less attention because it does not fit the familiar story.

The group has developed a shared interpersonal map.

And that map can influence how the person is treated.

Sometimes shared narratives reflect genuine patterns.

Other times, they become outdated or incomplete.

A person may change, but the group's understanding may remain relatively fixed.

This can create a difficult situation.

The person is responding to their current circumstances.

The group is responding to a map constructed from previous experiences.

When the map is not updated, the individual may struggle to be recognized as they are now.

The Influence of Social Maps on Our Behavior

Shared interpretations do more than influence what people believe.

They can also influence behavior.

Imagine that a new employee joins a team where one colleague has a reputation for being difficult.

Before meeting the colleague, the new employee has already heard several negative stories.

They approach the person cautiously.

They avoid asking for help.

They interpret ambiguous comments negatively.

The colleague notices the distance and becomes less approachable.

Now the new employee has a direct experience that seems to confirm the reputation.

This is where socially acquired information intersects with interpersonal expectancy effects.

Our expectations can influence how we behave.

Our behavior can influence how others respond.

Those responses then become additional information supporting the original expectation.

The process does not require anyone to be deliberately deceptive.

It can emerge through ordinary interpersonal interactions.

And once the pattern becomes established, it may be difficult to recognize how much of the relationship is being shaped by expectations that existed before the people involved had meaningful contact.

Therapists Help Draw Maps, Too

This process has important implications for psychotherapy.

Clients often come to therapy because they are trying to understand difficult experiences.

They may be struggling with confusing relationships, painful memories, recurring interpersonal patterns, or uncertainty about what happened.

Therapists help clients explore these experiences.

We ask questions.

We offer psychoeducation.

We introduce concepts that may help explain patterns.

We develop clinical formulations.

And sometimes we suggest interpretations that clients had not previously considered.

These interventions can be valuable.

A therapist may help a client recognize coercive control, understand trauma responses, identify maladaptive interpersonal patterns, or develop language for previously confusing experiences.

But therapists also occupy positions of professional influence.

Our words can carry considerable weight.

When a therapist offers an interpretation, a client may reasonably assume that the interpretation reflects professional knowledge.

This creates an important responsibility.

We need to distinguish between what the client directly reports, what the available information supports, and what we are proposing as a possible explanation.

For example, there is a difference between saying:

"Your partner repeatedly monitored your communications and threatened consequences when you attempted to spend time with friends. Those behaviors are consistent with patterns commonly discussed in coercive control."

And saying:

"Your partner did those things because they wanted to destroy your independence."

The first statement connects observed behavior to a recognized pattern.

The second makes a more specific inference about intention.

That inference might be accurate, but it requires additional support.

Therapeutic interpretations should help clients develop clearer maps.

They should not replace the client's understanding with an explanation that becomes impossible to question.

When Clinical Formulations Become Shared Certainties

Therapists are also vulnerable to confirmation bias.

Once a clinician develops a formulation, subsequent information may be interpreted through that framework.

Imagine that a therapist conceptualizes a client's relationship as involving emotional avoidance.

The therapist begins noticing interactions that appear consistent with this explanation.

The client adopts the language.

They begin describing their partner as avoidant.

Over time, the formulation becomes a shared understanding.

But what happens when the partner behaves differently?

What if the client provides information that does not fit the original formulation?

Can the therapist and client reconsider their understanding?

Or does every new behavior become additional evidence of avoidance?

Clinical formulations should remain open to revision.

This does not mean therapists should avoid offering interpretations.

It means interpretations should remain connected to the evidence available.

A useful formulation helps organize information while remaining responsive to new observations.

It should not become a closed explanation that absorbs every possible outcome.

Radical Openness and Social Influence

Radically Open Dialectical Behavior Therapy, or RO-DBT, emphasizes openness to new information, self-enquiry, and flexible responding.

These principles can help us examine how other people influence our interpersonal maps.

Radical openness does not mean accepting every interpretation someone offers.

It does not require us to assume that another person's perspective is more accurate than our own.

And it does not mean abandoning conclusions supported by substantial evidence.

Instead, radical openness encourages us to consider information thoughtfully.

When someone offers a different interpretation, we can ask:

What information are they using?

Did they directly observe the event?

Are they offering an inference or describing something they know?

Does their perspective help explain information I had not considered?

Does it conflict with credible evidence I already have?

Am I accepting the interpretation because it is well supported or because I trust the person offering it?

These questions allow us to remain open without becoming indiscriminately persuaded.

They also help us recognize that disagreement does not automatically mean someone is wrong.

Two people may have access to different information.

They may have noticed different aspects of an interaction.

They may be interpreting the same behavior through different experiences.

Understanding those differences can expand our maps.

When Outside Perspectives Become Harmful

Social influence can also become harmful.

In abusive or coercive relationships, people may be repeatedly told that their perceptions are inaccurate, that their emotional responses are unreasonable, or that events did not occur as they remember them.

These messages can undermine confidence in personal judgment.

Similarly, communities may pressure individuals to adopt particular interpretations of relationships or events.

People may be encouraged to disregard their own observations in favor of a group's preferred explanation.

This is why examining epistemic provenance is so important.

We need to distinguish between information that genuinely expands our understanding and information that pressures us to abandon credible experiences.

Sometimes outside perspectives help us recognize harm.

Sometimes they obscure it.

The goal is not to privilege individual perception over social information in every situation.

It is to evaluate the quality and relevance of the information available.

A person's direct experience matters.

So does credible information from others.

Neither should automatically erase the other.

A Small Exercise: Who Helped Draw This Part of My Map?

Think about a belief you hold about someone in your life.

Choose a relationship that feels safe enough to examine.

Consider the following questions.

  1. What do I currently believe about this person?

Describe your understanding as clearly as possible.

  1. What have I directly experienced?

Identify behaviors, conversations, or patterns you personally observed.

  1. What have other people told me?

Consider information acquired from friends, family members, colleagues, therapists, or other sources.

  1. What interpretations have other people offered?

Distinguish descriptions of events from explanations about motives or intentions.

  1. How has this information influenced my understanding?

Notice whether your interpretation changed after discussing the relationship with others.

  1. What information supports my current belief?

Consider the quality of the evidence rather than simply the number of people who agree.

  1. Is there credible information that might expand or refine my map?

This does not require abandoning a well-supported conclusion. It simply invites you to consider whether your understanding remains responsive to meaningful information.

You may discover that outside perspectives helped you recognize an important pattern.

You may realize that some parts of your understanding came from interpretations rather than direct observations.

Or you may find that your map has developed through a combination of experiences and social information.

The goal is not to determine whether other people have influenced you.

They almost certainly have.

The goal is to understand how that influence has shaped what you believe.

We Do Not Draw Our Maps Alone

Our interpersonal maps are shaped by much more than our individual experiences.

They develop through conversations, relationships, shared memories, cultural expectations, professional interpretations, and information acquired from the people around us.

Sometimes other people help us recognize what we could not see.

They provide language for complicated experiences.

They identify patterns.

They challenge assumptions.

And they help us understand relationships with greater clarity.

Other times, social influence introduces interpretations that become more convincing through repetition, familiarity, or agreement.

The challenge is not to stop listening to other people.

It is to remain aware of how their perspectives contribute to our understanding.

We can value outside information without treating every interpretation as fact.

We can recognize the importance of shared experiences without assuming that agreement automatically establishes accuracy.

We can learn from others while remaining attentive to what we have directly observed.

And we can revise our interpersonal maps when credible new information becomes available.

Perhaps one of the most useful questions we can ask is not simply, "What do I believe about this person?"

Perhaps we should also ask, "How did I come to believe it?"

Because understanding the territory requires more than examining the map itself.

Sometimes we also need to understand who helped draw it.

Coming Next in The Maps We Carry

In our next article, "When the Map Was Drawn in Survival Mode: Trauma and Interpersonal Expectations," we will explore how traumatic experiences can influence the development of interpersonal maps.

We will examine why protective expectations often emerge for good reasons, how those expectations can influence later relationships, and why psychological flexibility should never require someone to disregard genuine danger.

The Maps We Carry is an educational series based on the Cartographic Model of Interpersonal Meaning-Making, developed by Emily Williams, LPC/S, LAC/S, MAC, DBT-LBC, of Upstate Integrative Mind Counseling.

Foundational Reading

Williams, E. (2026, October). When the map becomes the territory: A model of interpersonal meaning-making. Psychotherapy Bulletin, 62(1).

Johnson, M. K., Hashtroudi, S., & Lindsay, D. S. (1993). Source monitoring. Psychological Bulletin, 114(1), 3–28.

Maswood, R., & Rajaram, S. (2019). Social transmission of false memory in small groups and large networks. Topics in Cognitive Science, 11(4), 687–709.

Snyder, M., & Stukas, A. A., Jr. (1999). Interpersonal processes: The interplay of cognitive, motivational, and behavioral activities in social interaction. Annual Review of Psychology, 50, 273–303.

Nickerson, R. S. (1998). Confirmation bias: A ubiquitous phenomenon in many guises. Review of General Psychology, 2(2), 175–220.

Previous
Previous

The Maps We Carry: When the Map Was Drawn in Survival Mode

Next
Next

The Maps We Carry: Cartographic Foreclosure, When Nothing Can Change Our Minds