Why We Notice What We Already Believe and How Our Expectations Shape the Stories We Tell
Have you ever noticed that once you form an opinion about someone, everything they do seems to reinforce it?
Perhaps you have a coworker you believe is judgmental.
When they ask a question about your work, it feels like criticism. When they offer a suggestion, it feels like they are questioning your competence. When they remain silent during a meeting, you wonder whether they disapprove of what you said.
Or perhaps you believe someone is particularly thoughtful.
When they remember a small detail about your life, you see it as evidence of their kindness. When they forget something important, you assume they were busy or distracted.
The interesting thing is that we may interpret similar behaviors very differently depending on what we already believe about the person.
Our expectations influence what we notice, how we interpret information, and which experiences become particularly memorable.
This process is related to confirmation bias.
And while confirmation bias is often discussed as though it is simply a problem with thinking, its role in relationships is considerably more complicated.
Sometimes our expectations help us recognize meaningful patterns.
Sometimes they protect us from repeated harm.
And sometimes they make it difficult to see information that does not fit the map we have already created.
What Is Confirmation Bias?
Confirmation bias refers to the tendency to seek, interpret, or give greater weight to information that supports an existing belief or expectation.
It is a well-established concept in psychological research.
In his influential review of confirmation bias, psychologist Raymond Nickerson described how people can favor information consistent with their existing beliefs across many different situations.
This does not mean that people deliberately ignore evidence or consciously manipulate information.
Often, these processes occur without our awareness.
Our minds are constantly organizing enormous amounts of information.
We cannot pay equal attention to everything happening around us.
Instead, we use existing knowledge and expectations to help determine what seems important.
In many circumstances, this is useful.
If someone has repeatedly demonstrated that they are dependable, we do not need to question their reliability every time we interact.
If someone has consistently violated our boundaries, we may reasonably anticipate similar behavior in the future.
Our expectations help us navigate relationships efficiently.
The difficulty arises when we begin interpreting nearly everything through an established belief without adequately considering credible information that challenges it.
How Confirmation Bias Shapes Our Interpersonal Maps
In the Cartographic Model of Interpersonal Meaning-Making, I propose that we construct interpersonal maps using information from direct experiences, emotions, memories, expectations, inferences, and information acquired from other people.
These maps help us understand relationships.
They also influence what we expect to encounter.
Imagine that you have developed the belief that a particular friend is selfish.
Perhaps the belief emerged after several disappointing interactions.
You remember times when they canceled plans, failed to check on you, or talked extensively about their own problems.
Over time, you begin expecting them to behave selfishly.
Now imagine that your friend calls to tell you about a difficult day.
You may immediately notice that they are talking about themselves again.
Their behavior seems to confirm your existing understanding.
But perhaps you overlook the fact that they asked about your week at the beginning of the conversation.
Or maybe you forget that they helped you through a difficult situation several months earlier.
Those details do not necessarily disprove your belief.
Your friend may genuinely have a pattern of prioritizing their own needs.
But confirmation bias can influence which information receives the most attention and how much importance we assign to it.
The interpersonal map becomes a framework through which subsequent experiences are interpreted.
And the more familiar that framework becomes, the more natural it may feel to use it.
The Difference Between Recognizing a Pattern and Looking for Confirmation
One of the most important distinctions in understanding confirmation bias is recognizing that not every established belief represents biased thinking.
Sometimes we develop expectations because someone has demonstrated a consistent pattern of behavior.
Imagine that you have a family member who repeatedly makes critical comments about your appearance.
You have addressed the behavior several times.
They continue making similar comments.
Eventually, you begin expecting criticism when you spend time together.
Is that confirmation bias?
Not necessarily.
Your expectation may reflect a reasonable conclusion based on repeated experiences.
Now imagine that the family member makes another critical comment.
Recognizing that the behavior fits an established pattern does not automatically mean you are interpreting the situation unfairly.
The concern arises when we begin treating ambiguous or contradictory information as though it must support the same conclusion.
For example, perhaps the family member offers a sincere compliment.
You immediately conclude that the compliment must be sarcastic.
They apologize for previous comments.
You decide that the apology must be manipulative.
They change their behavior over time.
You assume the change is temporary or insincere, regardless of what you observe.
Any one of these interpretations could be correct.
People sometimes offer insincere compliments, manipulative apologies, or temporary changes in behavior.
The important question is whether the interpretation is supported by the available information.
Can we distinguish between evidence of a repeated pattern and an assumption that every future behavior must fit that pattern?
Can credible new information influence our understanding?
Or has the conclusion become increasingly resistant to revision?
Why Contradictory Information Can Feel Uncomfortable
Our beliefs help us organize the world.
They provide predictability.
When we believe we understand another person's behavior, we can anticipate what may happen and decide how to respond.
But what happens when someone behaves differently than we expected?
Imagine that you believe your supervisor dislikes you.
You have spent months interpreting their feedback as evidence of dissatisfaction.
Then, during a performance review, your supervisor offers substantial praise.
They describe your work as valuable and express appreciation for your contributions.
This information does not fit neatly within your existing understanding.
You may feel confused.
Perhaps you wonder whether they are simply being polite.
Maybe you suspect they have an ulterior motive.
Or perhaps you begin reconsidering your earlier interpretation.
Contradictory information can create discomfort because it challenges an established understanding.
If we revise the map, we may also need to reconsider previous experiences.
Maybe the supervisor's feedback was not always intended as criticism.
Maybe some of the interactions we interpreted negatively had different explanations.
Or perhaps the supervisor's attitude has genuinely changed.
There may be several possibilities.
The challenge is allowing new information to be considered without automatically forcing it into the existing interpretation.
When Every Outcome Confirms the Same Belief
Consider a relationship in which one person believes the other is intentionally manipulative.
If the person reaches out, the contact is interpreted as an attempt to gain control.
If they withdraw, the withdrawal is interpreted as punishment.
If they apologize, the apology is interpreted as manipulation.
If they do not apologize, the absence of an apology is interpreted as evidence that they lack remorse.
If they agree with the person's account of an event, the agreement is interpreted as an attempt to maintain influence.
If they disagree, the disagreement is interpreted as dishonesty.
Notice what happens.
Every possible response appears to support the original conclusion.
This is where the discussion moves beyond ordinary confirmation bias.
In my Cartographic Model, I propose the term cartographic foreclosure to describe reduced openness to revising an interpersonal representation when credible information that does not fit the established map becomes available.
Cartographic foreclosure is a proposed conceptual construct, not an established diagnosis or independently validated psychological measure.
It describes a particular concern about interpersonal meaning-making.
What happens when an established understanding becomes capable of explaining every possible outcome?
If no credible information could change the conclusion, the map may become insulated from the territory.
However, there is an essential distinction here.
A person may reasonably maintain a conclusion about someone who has demonstrated a longstanding pattern of harmful behavior.
Remaining confident in a well-supported assessment is not evidence of psychological rigidity.
The question is not whether someone changes their mind whenever contradictory information appears.
The question is whether credible contradictory information is genuinely considered.
Confirmation Bias and Our Emotional Experiences
Confirmation bias does not operate independently of emotion.
Our emotional experiences can influence which information seems particularly important.
If we feel rejected, we may become especially attentive to signs of exclusion.
If we feel angry, we may notice behavior that appears disrespectful or unfair.
If we feel ashamed, we may interpret ambiguous feedback as criticism.
If we feel afraid, we may become more attentive to potential threats.
These responses can serve important protective functions.
But they can also influence how we interpret interpersonal situations.
Imagine that you attend a social gathering while feeling insecure about whether you belong.
Someone across the room laughs while talking with another person.
You wonder whether they are laughing at you.
Later, someone fails to acknowledge you when you walk past.
You interpret the behavior as further evidence that you are unwelcome.
By the end of the evening, you may feel certain that people were excluding you.
Perhaps they were.
But perhaps the laughter was unrelated to you, and the person who failed to acknowledge you simply did not notice you.
The available information may not be sufficient to determine what happened.
Yet your emotional state may have influenced which details you noticed and how you connected them.
This is one way confirmation bias and emotional reasoning can interact.
An emotional response makes an interpretation feel convincing.
The interpretation influences what we notice.
What we notice then reinforces the emotional response.
Over time, the cycle can strengthen an interpersonal belief.
When Our Beliefs Change How We Behave
Confirmation bias can also become part of an interpersonal feedback loop.
Suppose you believe a friend is becoming distant.
You begin monitoring their behavior for signs of withdrawal.
You notice delayed responses, shorter conversations, and changes in their availability.
You become anxious and begin seeking reassurance.
Your friend feels overwhelmed by the repeated questions.
They start responding less frequently.
Now their behavior appears to confirm your original concern.
You become more convinced that the friendship is deteriorating.
Your expectations influenced your behavior, which may have influenced the other person's response.
That response then became additional information supporting the original belief.
This does not mean the friend was never becoming distant.
It also does not mean that seeking reassurance caused the entire problem.
Relationships involve multiple people, each with their own experiences, needs, and choices.
But it illustrates how our beliefs can influence the interactions that later become evidence for those same beliefs.
Understanding this process can help us recognize opportunities for greater flexibility.
The Role of Other People in Reinforcing Our Maps
Our interpersonal beliefs are not developed in isolation.
We talk to friends, family members, therapists, coworkers, and others about our experiences.
These conversations can provide valuable support and perspective.
But they can also influence which interpretations become more convincing.
Imagine that you have a difficult interaction with a coworker.
You tell a friend what happened.
Your friend responds, "That sounds like they're jealous of you."
You had not considered jealousy as an explanation.
But now you begin thinking about previous interactions through that possibility.
Later, you discuss the situation with another person who agrees.
Over time, the interpretation may become increasingly familiar.
You may begin noticing behaviors that appear consistent with jealousy while overlooking other explanations.
This does not mean that the interpretation is necessarily wrong.
Perhaps the coworker really is behaving competitively.
The important distinction is between information that supports a conclusion and agreement from people who may be relying on the same limited account.
Several people agreeing with an interpretation does not automatically establish that the interpretation is accurate.
At the same time, outside perspectives can help us recognize patterns we might otherwise miss.
Sometimes other people notice harmful behavior that we have normalized.
Sometimes they provide information that challenges an inaccurate assumption.
And sometimes they help us consider explanations we had not previously recognized.
The value of outside perspectives depends partly on the information available and how thoughtfully it is considered.
Confirmation Bias in Psychotherapy
Therapists are not immune to confirmation bias.
Clinical training provides frameworks for understanding behavior, but those frameworks can also influence what clinicians notice.
Imagine that a therapist develops a formulation suggesting that a client frequently avoids emotionally difficult experiences.
During subsequent sessions, the therapist may become particularly attentive to behaviors that appear consistent with avoidance.
If the client changes the subject, the therapist may interpret it as avoidance.
If the client expresses uncertainty about an intervention, the therapist may interpret it as avoidance.
If the client misses an appointment, the therapist may interpret it as avoidance.
Sometimes those interpretations may be accurate.
But other explanations may also deserve consideration.
Perhaps the client changed the subject because they needed additional context.
Perhaps their uncertainty reflects a legitimate concern about the intervention.
Perhaps the missed appointment resulted from an unrelated practical difficulty.
A clinical formulation should help organize information.
It should not become an explanation that automatically absorbs every new observation.
This is why consultation, supervision, and ongoing self-enquiry are important.
Clinicians need to remain willing to examine their assumptions.
What information supports the formulation?
What information does not fit?
Are there alternative explanations?
What would lead me to revise my understanding?
These questions help protect against a formulation becoming more rigid than the evidence supports.
Radical Openness Is Not the Same as Being Easily Persuaded
Radically Open Dialectical Behavior Therapy, or RO-DBT, emphasizes openness to new information, flexible responding, and self-enquiry.
These principles offer a useful way to examine confirmation bias.
Radical openness does not mean accepting every alternative explanation.
It does not mean treating all perspectives as equally credible.
And it does not mean abandoning a well-supported conclusion simply because someone disagrees.
Instead, radical openness involves being willing to consider information that may challenge our expectations.
We can ask ourselves:
What do I believe about this person?
What experiences contributed to that belief?
What information am I noticing most readily?
Is there information I may be overlooking?
Am I interpreting ambiguous behavior through an established expectation?
What credible information would make me reconsider my understanding?
These questions invite curiosity without requiring self-invalidation.
Sometimes the answers reinforce our original conclusion.
Sometimes they reveal a more complicated picture.
And sometimes they help us recognize that our expectations have become more certain than the available information supports.
When Openness Becomes Unsafe
There is an important safeguard in this discussion.
Confirmation bias should never become a convenient explanation for dismissing someone's concerns about abuse, coercion, discrimination, exploitation, or other forms of harm.
People can accurately recognize patterns of mistreatment.
They can reasonably develop expectations based on repeated experiences.
And they can establish boundaries without being required to continually reconsider whether someone intended to hurt them.
A person who has experienced repeated threats does not need to expose themselves to additional danger to demonstrate psychological flexibility.
Someone who has documented a pattern of coercive behavior does not need to assume that every new interaction represents an opportunity for reconciliation.
A well-supported conclusion may remain appropriate even when another person offers a competing interpretation.
The goal is not endless uncertainty.
The goal is a thoughtful relationship with evidence.
Sometimes a map accurately identifies dangerous territory.
And when it does, the map should help us remain safe.
A Small Exercise: Looking for What Does Not Fit
Think about a relationship in which you have developed a strong belief about another person.
Choose a situation that feels safe enough to examine with curiosity.
Consider the following questions.
What is my current belief about this person?
Try to describe it clearly.
What experiences contributed to that belief?
Identify specific behaviors or patterns rather than relying only on general impressions.
What information supports my understanding?
Consider direct observations, repeated experiences, and credible information from other sources.
What information might not fit?
Are there meaningful exceptions, changes, or alternative explanations?
How do I interpret information that challenges my belief?
Do I consider it carefully, dismiss it immediately, or assume it must somehow reinforce my original conclusion?
What would meaningful new information look like?
Consider what could reasonably strengthen, weaken, or refine your understanding.
What boundaries or protections remain appropriate?
Remember that examining an interpretation does not require changing boundaries or exposing yourself to harm.
You may discover that your belief remains well supported.
You may recognize that certain assumptions deserve reconsideration.
Or you may find that your understanding is more complicated than you previously realized.
The purpose is not to force yourself to change your mind.
It is to understand how your mind responds to information that fits and does not fit the map you already carry.
The Challenge of Seeing Beyond What We Expect
Confirmation bias is part of ordinary human thinking.
Our minds use previous experiences to organize information, recognize patterns, and anticipate what might happen next.
These processes help us navigate a complicated social world.
But our expectations can also influence which details we notice, how we interpret ambiguous behavior, and what we remember about relationships.
Sometimes those expectations are accurate.
Sometimes they are incomplete.
And sometimes they become so familiar that we stop recognizing how much they influence our understanding.
The challenge is not to abandon our beliefs.
It is to remain aware that our beliefs influence how we encounter new information.
We can recognize patterns without assuming every future interaction must follow them.
We can maintain boundaries without automatically assigning motives to every behavior.
We can trust our experiences while remaining curious about what we may not yet know.
And we can consider credible contradictory information without treating disagreement itself as proof that our understanding is wrong.
Perhaps the most useful question is not simply, "What evidence supports what I believe?"
Perhaps we should also ask, "What evidence would I be willing to consider if it challenged what I believe?"
Because sometimes the map is accurate.
Sometimes the territory has changed.
And sometimes we have become so familiar with our map that we have stopped looking closely at the landscape around us.
Coming Next in The Maps We Carry
In our next article, "Cartographic Foreclosure: When Nothing Can Change Our Minds," we will explore what happens when interpersonal beliefs become increasingly resistant to revision.
We will examine how a belief can begin explaining every possible outcome, why this differs from justified confidence, and how radical openness can help us remain responsive to credible information without abandoning our experiences or boundaries.
The Maps We Carry is an educational series based on the Cartographic Model of Interpersonal Meaning-Making, developed by Emily Williams, LPC/S, LAC/S, MAC, DBT-LBC, of Upstate Integrative Mind Counseling.
Foundational Reading
Williams, E. (2026, October). When the map becomes the territory: A model of interpersonal meaning-making. Psychotherapy Bulletin, 62(1).
Nickerson, R. S. (1998). Confirmation bias: A ubiquitous phenomenon in many guises. Review of General Psychology, 2(2), 175–220.
Anglin, S. M. (2019). Do beliefs yield to evidence? Examining belief perseverance vs. change in response to congruent empirical findings. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 82, 176–199.
Lynch, T. R., Hempel, R. J., & Dunkley, C. (2015). Radically open-dialectical behavior therapy for disorders of over-control: Signaling matters. American Journal of Psychotherapy, 69(2), 141–162.

